Home>Column>Letter: Southampton Can Have Clean Water Without Sacrificing Its Park
The Southampton Village Dog Park, which would be moved to make way for the leaching field for the sewage treatment plant.
Column Letters Opinion

Letter: Southampton Can Have Clean Water Without Sacrificing Its Park

To the Editor:

Lola Prentice Memorial Park should not be sacrificed for wastewater infrastructure. Southampton deserves clean water and a planning process that protects public land.

A 2019 injunction restricts the park to park use. Litigation now challenges the Village Board’s attempt to pursue parkland alienation. Residents deserve a clear explanation of how the proposal respects that court order.


Pictured Above: Lola Prentice Memorial Park, which could be moved to make way for the leaching field for a sewage treatment plant.


Moving the treatment building to 151 Windmill Lane does not preserve the park if 185 Windmill Lane becomes the sewage-effluent disposal site. Replacement acreage cannot automatically replace the park’s recreational, landscape, and environmental functions.

Our environmental dossier and Evidence Matrix and FOIL Source Report connect 54 issues to identified sources, with 41 reproduced record files totaling 412 source pages. They raise serious questions about the voard’s oversight, its consultants, and public participation.

Engineering requests in 2021 anticipated a Negative Declaration before the later environmental-significance decision. Committee notes recorded a decision against public input during proposal vetting because it would complicate and prolong the process. Meanwhile, park restrictions count against some alternative sites while this proposal requiring parkland alienation remains under consideration.

The technical concerns are equally serious. Project records identify high groundwater, reduced discharge capacity, and the need for groundwater-mounding analysis. Concentrated recharge could affect neighboring properties and the historic North End Burying Ground, whose oldest recorded burial dates to 1721. These are unresolved risks requiring seasonal measurements, soil testing, and independently reviewed modeling before committing the park.

Alternatives deserve consistent engineering and cost comparisons: the municipal works campus at 100-104 Willow Street, municipal parking at 27 West Main Street, and Powell Avenue/Railroad Plaza station parking. Each has constraints that require investigation; none should be dismissed without a fair assessment. Treatment and recharge at separate locations also deserve evaluation, as project correspondence expressly discusses.

Residents also deserve the complete bill. The $20.92 million Phase I application covers collection and conveyance, not the entire system. Disclose treatment, recharge, land, hookups, displacement, mitigation, monitoring, and lifetime operating costs.

The board should retain Lola Prentice Memorial Park, commission independent technical review, compare park-preserving alternatives fairly, and answer the documented evidence in writing. It has not demonstrated that improving water quality requires surrendering this park.

Blaise F. Labriola
Southampton Village


Letters to the editor may be emailed to editor@eastendbeacon.com with “LTE” in the subject line, or sent via U.S. Post to P.O. Box 665, New Suffolk, NY  11956. Please include your name, and a telephone number for verification purposes, and don’t submit letters under false names. The Beacon will print all letters that are deemed to not be defamatory, obscene or advertisements, and may edit submissions for clarity and grammar. Due to space considerations we are only able to print one letter per writer per month, and we may shorten lengthy letters in print to fit available space.

Beth Young
Beth Young is an award-winning local journalist who has been covering the East End since the 1990s. She began her career at the Sag Harbor Express and has reported for the Southampton Press, the East Hampton Press and the Times/Review Media Group. She founded the East End Beacon website in 2013, and a print edition in 2017. Beth was born and raised on the North Fork. In her spare time, she tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at editor@eastendbeacon.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human: