Patrolling the Pine Barrens

State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata patrol the pine barrens.
State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata patrol the pine barrens.

In the depths of winter and the heat of summer, for the past 15 years, law enforcement teams have been taking to the woods of the Central Pine Barrens twice per month to crack down on the illegal use of all-terrain vehicles in the vast swaths of preserved land throughout central Long Island.

Drawing from DEC Environmental Conservation Police and Forest Rangers, New York State Troopers and and Suffolk County Park Rangers, Police and Deputy Sheriffs, about a half dozen teams of two officers can be found on any given detail searching for illegal activities in the woods.

The Multi-Agency ATV Task Force Detail, organized by the Central Pine Barrens Commission, is lead by Arthur Pendzick, a longtime Suffolk County Park Ranger who has served as the Chairman of the Suffolk County Pine Barrens Law Enforcement Association.

“ATVs tear up pine barrens trails,” he said on a recent Saturday, as he met up with law enforcement teams on quads at the New York State Trooper barracks in Riverside. He added that riders of ATVs often scare hikers, horseback riders and mountain bikers in the woods, as well as making a lot of noise that annoys homeowners in the pine barrens and also scares animals.

“People have been thrown off of horseback, and bikers have fallen off their bikes” when passed by a speeding ATV, he said, adding that some high tension electric wire towers in the depths of the pine barrens are beginning to lean because of the erosion caused by dirt bikes and quads.

State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata patrol the pine barrens.

He frequently recalls one case of a man who lived next door to the woods in Wading River who was barbecuing one afternoon when a posse of ATVs drove by in the woods, kicking up a dust cloud that ruined $100 worth of steaks.

Finding people using ATVs in the woods isn’t an easy job. Ninety percent of suspects flee when they encounter law enforcement, and Mr. Pendzick has seen three officers get seriously hurt, one of whom is now in a wheelchair, while attempting to catch them. While the task force has a no-pursuit policy, he’s quick to point out that ATV users without a prior conviction who don’t flee simply face fines and the impounding of their quad or dirt bike, but if they flee and are caught they will face criminal charges.

ATVs and dirt bikes can’t be used on any public lands on Long Island, though they are legal upstate and can be used on private land, with the property owner’s permission.

But with 100,000 acres of preserved wild lands in the Central Pine Barrens, some people are still willing to risk a ride through the woods, believing it is unlikely they will be caught. They need to be observed in action by the police in order to receive a citation, so without the patrols in the woods, finding them would be a near-impossible task.

Suffolk County has, at times, provided a helicopter or small plane to assist in locating ATVs during the task force details.

On a recent brisk Saturday, with a light dusting of snow on the ground, State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata headed out from the Riverside barracks to search the woods in East Quogue for ATV riders. They were cheerful, despite the cold. The sky was clear and they were looking ahead to a several hour shift doing a job that they love.

They pointed out that, while they will be in the woods for several hours, most recreational ATV users will only be in the woods for about an hour. The greatest ATV activity is in late afternoon, just before dinner, and after school during the week — the details are held at constantly changing times and locations, to give officers the element of surprise.

Mr. Pendzick and Suffolk County Park Ranger Ryan Hutnick, who were acting as scouts on this day’s detail, mused about the Southampton Town Board’s recent decision to nix a proposed golf course and housing development not far from where they were, a 168-acre site on Spinney Road.

That property, they said, was one where they’d found ATV riders in the past.

State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata.
State Troopers Fabio Daino and Peter Nunziata.

As they headed out to scout more areas in the woods, Mr. Pendzick reflected on the lessons learned from the past 15 years, during which time he’s seen a sharp decline in the number of ATVs in the woods here.

Still, he said, many parents buy ATVs for their kids for Christmas — they can be sold on Long Island, though dealers are required to let customers know they can’t be ridden on public lands here.

“People get hurt and killed on ATVs,” he said. “Kids don’t register or insure them, and it becomes a major issue. New York has the eighth highest ATV fatality rate in the country.”

Later that day, according to their report for the shift, officers from the five teams working encountered a large group of riders in the Setauket Woods who managed to evade officers, and “a large side-by-side who escaped by plowing through a barricade.

They impounded a quad being ridden by a 13-year-old in the woods off Route 112 in Port Jefferson Station, and then again impunded  an ATV in the woods off of Weeks Avenue in Manorville. The rider in that case had an active warrant for vehicle and traffic violations, and was taken to the Suffolk County Jail.

Summonses were also given to riders in the woods off Mill Road in Yaphank and Weeks Road in Manorville.

By the end of the day, they’d brought the year’s total impounds to 72, with 155 summonses issued.

Officers ask the public to report illegal ATV use in the Pine Barrens to 1-877-BARRENS.

Beth Young

Beth Young has been covering the East End since the 1990s. In her spare time, she runs around the block, tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at

6 thoughts on “Patrolling the Pine Barrens

  • January 14, 2018 at 10:52 am

    This is a great article, illuminating a local issue I knew nothing about. I hate the idea of ATVs in national parks out west, but I had no idea the problem hit so close to home.

  • January 23, 2018 at 2:56 pm

    I have been walking and working on Suffolk County’s beautiful nature and recreational trails for the last 27 years. I can tell you without exaggeration that if the trails continue to absorb the same amount of punishment they are subject to now, nobody will want to walk on them in another 10 to 15 years. There is over 1000 miles of land manager sanctioned trails, mostly built by a few handfuls of volunteers. For a while we will be able to constantly narrow where we walk to just the undamaged or lightly damaged trails without noticing a restriction in venue. If the damage was to stop today, it would take those few handfuls of volunteers about 10 years to repair the damage already done. The way they would do this is by closing down the trails that have become ravines and gully’s, remediating the distortion in the hydrology with grading and logs, and then replacing the damaged trails with sustainably built trails. These sustainably built trails, if used gently and maintained properly could last forever. Enforcement is doing a lot to slow down the destruction, but they are only buying us time. Let’s use that time to come up with more effective methods of protecting this vital resource.
    I keep hearing that this is a problem that will never go away, is that the refrain I would hear if all our museums were getting trashed, our banks robbed? Don’t lose sight of the value of what we are losing. We must do more to protect our natural open space and trails, NOW.
    One thing you could do is to determine if the local retailers are conforming to the law (excerpt follows):
    Suffolk County, NY Local Law To Require Truth-in-selling Statement for ATVs
    C.) Any business organization, including, but not limited to, any individual, corporation, unincorporated association, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, joint stock association, or other entity of any kind who sells or offers for sale an ATV to any person, within the County of Suffolk for compensation, shall disclose, in writing, the restrictions set forth in paragraphs (A) and (B) of this section by conspicuously posting a statement of these restrictions at each point of sale (all capital letters not less than two (2) inches in height on a contrasting background). This statement shall read as follows:

    The purchaser shall also be provided with a written copy of this statement by the seller at the conclusion of the purchase of the ATV.

  • March 4, 2019 at 4:21 pm

    Thank god I live out west and have access to trails for dirt bikes , ATV’s, horses etc. We are responsible trail users. You’re liberal utopia is making good people criminals.

  • March 6, 2019 at 7:45 am

    living in new York must be a lot like going to hell…..

  • January 21, 2021 at 7:11 pm

    For decades people have been asking for a legal place to ride with no avail. NYS DMV however has no issue taking registration and plate fees for ATVs, yet not a single inch of park land to ride like many other states provide. Just another reason to get out of LI/NY and go elsewhere…. Just don’t go and vote for the same things you left behind.
    For the record I don’t approve of riding ATVs in the Pine Barrens.

  • September 20, 2021 at 10:35 pm

    Cant do anything in New York! This is such a waste of tax money! Using atvs to catch people doing the same exact thing, makes perfect sense. Go fight real crime


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human:

%d bloggers like this: