The Otis Pike National Wilderness on Fire Island
The Otis Pike National Wilderness on Fire Island

Maverick U.S. Congressman Otis Pike, who died in hospice care in Florida Monday at the age of 92, had an unlikely life for Riverhead son.

During his 18 years as a Democratic Representative from what was then a staunchly Republican region, Mr. Pike used to quip that, on Eastern Long Island, he was “surrounded on three sides by water and on the fourth by Republicans.”

Otis Pike
Otis Pike

It was his early days in Riverhead, however, that formed his political views.

Mr. Pike was born on Aug. 31, 1921. His parents died when he was six, and he was raised by his older sisters and his aunt. One of his sisters, who was a social worker, once took him out to visit another Riverhead family for dinner during the Great Depression.

“All they had for Sunday dinner was boiled potatoes,” he told The New Yorker in 1967. “I was surprised that in a great country like America such a thing could happen. All my family had always been Republicans, but that kind of thing, and what Franklin Roosevelt tried to do about it, turned me into a Democrat.”

Mr. Pike was a fighter pilot who flew 120 missions in the Pacific Theater during World War II, after which he received his law degree from Columbia University and came home to Riverhead, where he practiced law and served on the town board and as a justice of the peace until he was elected to Congress in 1960.

It was then that he began making waves on the world stage. He began questioning Defense Department spending during the Vietnam War, and was credited with killing a $14 million plan that would have given flight duty pay to desk-bound admirals and generals.

Wearing his trademark bow tie and wildly simulating an airplane in flight with his arms, Mr. Pike elaborated on the plan in 1973  on the floor of the House:

“If the in-basket is continually loaded on the starboard, or right-hand, side of the desk, and the out-basket is continually empty on the port, or left-hand, side of the desk,wood fatigue sets in, the landing gear tends to buckle and the whole fuselage crashes down on your feet,” he said, receiving a roar of laughter from Congress in response.

It was not long after that speech, in 1975, that Mr. Pike was put in charge of the House Select Committee on Intelligence, which was charged with investigating the CIA’s role in coups in Chile and assassinations in other countries, and illegal spying on anti-war protestors at home.

He retired from Congress in 1978, telling The Washington Post that the job was no longer fun and that Congress had become dominated by two types of people: millionaires and Boy Scouts.

The current House Intelligence Committee Chairman, Mike Rogers (R-Mich.), was one of the first to praise Mr. Pike after he died Monday.

“We mourn today the passing of Congressman Otis Pike, who led a groundbreaking House oversight investigation of CIA activities. The U.S. Intelligence Community receives closer scrutiny today than ever in the history of our country. That, in large part, is due to the work of Otis Pike,” he said in a statement to reporters.

The East End’s current Congressman, Tim Bishop, agreed.

“Congressman Pike was a tireless watchdog who made sure that the government was doing all it could to best serve the interests of the public. He led the first Congressional investigation into the activities of the CIA and fought to curtail waste in military spending,” ” he said in a statement Monday.  “Congressman Pike was an admirable and dedicated public servant, and one whose career should serve as a model for all who are engaged in public service.”

Throughout his life, Mr. Pike spent a great deal of time on boats and in nature, and several preserves on Long Island now bear his name, including the Otis Pike National Wilderness on Fire Island and the Otis Pike Ponds in Calverton.

Mr. Pike is survived by his second wife, Barbe Bonjour Pike, his son Douglas, his daughter, Lois Pike Eyre and two grandchildren. HIs first wife, Doris Orth, died in 1996 and his son, Robert, died in 2010.


Beth Young
Beth Young is an award-winning local journalist who has been covering the East End since the 1990s. She began her career at the Sag Harbor Express and, after receiving her Masters from the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, has reported for the Southampton Press, the East Hampton Press and the Times/Review Media Group. She founded the East End Beacon website in 2013, and a print edition in 2017. Beth was born and raised on the North Fork. In her spare time, she tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at

2 thoughts on “Remembering Otis Pike

  1. Thanks, Beth, for a great tribute to a great man – Otis was among the East End’s best, and I pass along my condolences to his family as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human: