Pictured Above: (l-r) Southold Town Democratic candidates Gwynn Schroeder, Anne Smith, Al Krupski, Nick Krupski, Bill Flinter and Dan Ross.
Southold Democrats picked their slate for 2023 town elections Thursday night, choosing Suffolk County Legislator Al Krupski to run for Town Supervisor, along with former Mattituck-Cutchogue School District Superintendent Anne Smith and Mr. Krupski’s longtime legislative aide, Gwynn Schroeder, to run for Town Board.
Incumbent Democratic Councilwoman Sarah Nappa also announced at Thursday’s nominating convention that she will not run for re-election.
“I have so much respect for the work she’s done. It’s an incredible service. She really stood alone for several years, and it was not easy,” said Party Chair Kathryn Casey Quigley. Ms. Nappa, who was home with Covid, attended via Zoom.
Democrats declined to nominate a candidate for Town Trustee President, putting their faith in incumbent Republican Trustee President Glenn Goldsmith’s ability to work across the aisle, said Ms. Quigley.
Democrats did back incumbent Trustee Nick Krupski to run for a third term. They also support Town Justice Dan Ross for a second term, and are running William Flinter for Tax Assessor. Ms. Quigley said the party is still interviewing candidates for Tax Receiver.
Mr. Krupski, a Cutchogue resident who has run his family’s farm on the Main Road in Peconic for decades, has been in the Suffolk County Legislature for 10 years. He had previously served as a Southold Town Councilman for seven years, and a Southold Town Trustee for 20 years before that.
“When you look at this lineup here, it’s pretty impressive. It’s hard to get people to run for public office. It’s not really as glamorous as people think,” said Mr. Krupski as he accepted the nomination. “Growing up in this town, you really felt like this was really normal. You got to go through the farm fields or go play in the creek and the bay. You knew your neighbors. It really seemed like it was a normal existence. I gotta tell you, Southold is a special place. The rest of the world isn’t as normal as this. When you see the rest of the world, you realize how special Southold is.”
“It’s not just the clean water we raise shellfish in and swim in. It’s a sense of community,” he added. “A lot of people are very concerned because there are so many new people coming out here and really, we have to welcome everyone here and say join our community… Be part of our community. I think we’re all capable of doing that.”
“When there’s no headline because the roads are plowed, and there’s no headline because access isn’t cut off to the creek or the bay, that’s because the people in government are doing their jobs,” he said. “There’s a lot of good people in town who keep the wheels turning. But the community input to that government is really critical.”
“People said ‘finally. Yes! It’s time,'” Ms. Casey said of Ms. Schroeder’s candidacy. Ms. Schroeder has been active in supporting Democratic candidates on the North Fork for decades, and has also been an environmental leader with the North Fork Environmental Council and North Fork Audubon.
“Al is truly a statesman. I’ve learned so much from him over the past ten years. He knows when to fight, when to compromise, and when to push things forward. He’s passionate,” said Ms. Schroeder. “I think we as a community, and your elected officials, have to take control of the future of Southold. There are a lot of issues that are going to come down the pike in the next ten years, including climate change, our sole source aquifer — we have a water issue — and housing. I think we can have a healthy environment and provide affordable housing. We just have to do it the right way, and I don’t think building is one of the ways we’re going to do it.”
Ms. Smith, who retired as Superintendent in 2018, has since volunteered her time as a leader and President of the Mattituck-Laurel Civic Association, served on the Southold Town Police Review Task Force, chaired the North Fork Coalition for Behavioral Health to help provide mental health services for kids on the North Fork, and serves on the town’s Housing Advisory Commission.
Ms. Smith, a mother of three, lost her youngest son in 2021.
“That really changed our course,” she said of her family. “Finding myself on a new leadership path, while unexpected, is something I’m really ready to embrace. It really comes with the courage we’ve had as a family. We’re so grateful for the love of this community.”
Nick Krupski, Al Krupski’s son, read a quote from Dr. Seuss’s “The Lorax,” at the request of his daughter: “Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not.”
“I grew up in the creeks, crabbing and eeling and fishing and waterfowling, and it’s something I want to see continue on to the next generation,” he said.
Southold Town Republicans plan to unveil their 2023 slate at a campaign kickoff event at Osprey’s Dominion Vineyard on Thursday, March 9 at 6 p.m. Tickets are $75 per person, $125 per couple or $50 for committee members. To attend, RSVP to Jilld927@yahoo.com.


