An effort is underway to save the Witch's Hat on Route 25 in Aquebogue.
An effort is underway to save the Witch’s Hat on Route 25 in Aquebogue.

When I was just 18 years old, full of the excitement of a kid who’s just left home, I moved into a tiny cottage on the Main Road in Aquebogue. It was dangerous. Even back then, in the mid-90s, the traffic was unrelenting and sidewalks were few and far between. I didn’t have a car but I had a P.O. Box at the old Aquebogue Post Office and a baby in my belly just waiting to get out and taste this big world.

Windows to gaze out.
Windows to gaze out.

Every day of that year of pregnancy and stroller walks is like a dream memory. I can tell you every storm grate and every gnarled tree that uprooted the brief sections of sidewalk between my house near Route 105 and the bottom of the hill at the corner of Church Lane. I can remember every oversized envelope that I exchanged for a yellow slip in that old post office, each bearing a new selection from the Quality Paperback Book Club, and I can remember every time I walked back up the hill with a new catalog from Edward R. Hamilton’s remainder book sale newsletter. I remember the blooms on the flowers at the farm stands and nurseries and the never-ending new, complicated scents that you can only smell when you take the time to take a walk.

Across from the Aquebogue Veterinary Hospital is another hill that seemed pretty steep to someone who was about to have a baby. Smack dab in the middle of that hill is a big tree whose roots are uprooting the sidewalk. Under that tree, you can sit and stare for hours at the Witch’s Hat.

The peak.
The peak.

I didn’t know that the Witch’s Hat was called the Witch’s Hat until I heard last week that some people in Aquebogue are trying to save it. It’s just a little building on the edge of the driveway to the veterinary hospital, with a tall, conical roof and a lot of windows with little panes. I thought it was the most beautiful building of all time.

I thought it would be a good library for all the books I was collecting. I squinted and dreamed that I would some day build an exact replica of that building for a writing studio. I dreamed of the life of a hermit with a Royal Safari typewriter, who goes to town once a week to buy bacon and typewriter ribbons and check the post office for a letter from my editor.

Richard Wines, who knows just about everything about the history of Riverhead’s buildings, sent me what little is known about the history of the building: It was built by Harry Flemming, an English immigrant and machinist, in the early 1920s. It was known in those days as “The Lighthouse.” Estelle Evans told Riverhead’s Landmarks Preservation Commission in 1983 that there was a gas pump there that served as the primary income at the site, but you could buy candy, tobacco and eventually ice cream in the Lighthouse. In 1986, it was added to Riverhead’s landmark list, with a note that the veterinarian at the time, Dr. Brown, had recently reglazed the windows. The 1930 Census listed Mr. Flemming’s wife, Lena, as the head of the household at the address, after Mr. Flemming died. Lena was listed as the owner of a candy and cigarette store.


Now, the “Save Main Road” group, which has been active in efforts to keep a YMCA from being built just east of Aquebogue and is working to have the highway designated on the national register of historic places, is launching an effort to repair the Witch’s Hat.

It’s still owned by the animal hospital but it’s certainly seen better days. Veterinarian Richard Hanusch had been told in the past by builders that it would cost an arm and a leg to fix. So Save Main Road has set out to do the work themselves.

Volunteers will be needed soon to clean up the building, strip off the rotting shingles, install new shingles and paint. Carpentry skills will be helpful, but all hands are appreciated. More information is available here. If you want to volunteer your efforts, send an email to Mr. Wines at Without a doubt, you’ll see me there helping to restore a piece of all of our past.


Video by Cliff Baldwin for Save Main Road.

Beth Young
Beth Young is an award-winning local journalist who has been covering the East End since the 1990s. She began her career at the Sag Harbor Express and, after receiving her Masters from the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, has reported for the Southampton Press, the East Hampton Press and the Times/Review Media Group. She founded the East End Beacon website in 2013, and a print edition in 2017. Beth was born and raised on the North Fork. In her spare time, she tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at

3 thoughts on “Save the Lighthouse! Save the Witch’s Hat! Save Aquebogue!

  1. Beth, I remember when the local paper had a picture of Dr. Brown with the Witch’s Hat. He was going to restore the entire thing; said it was his “pet project.” Then he moved away and no one attended to it. It’s such a nice little building and I’m happy that it has a bright future. Thanks for the article.

  2. I do remember this structure very well. I spent much of my childhood growing up summer & winter with my Aunt & Uncle at their house on West Lane in Aquebogue

    (At Christmastime, I remember my Uncle offering guests smoked duck and warning them of the lead pellets inside before they bite down.) We did things without outside help.

    Putting out from Mettinghouse Creek at dawn. NIRVANA.

    I do hope The Witches Hat can be saved.

    PS: What ever happened to McKay’s Farm Stand ?
    DOES ANYONE REMEMBER SCOTTIE’S RABBIT FARM on West Lane, just north of the main road ???

  3. I bought our family pet, Einstein, a beautiful rabbit at Scottie’s Rabbit Farm on West Lane. Scotty thought I wanted the rabbit for dinner! That rabbit leaved 15 years! Salt hay in the winter created his den!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human: