Congressman Lee Zeldin announced Sunday that he expects his Plum Island bill to leave committee April 28.
Congressman Lee Zeldin announced Sunday that he expects his Plum Island bill to leave committee April 28.

Update April 29:The U.S. House of Representatives Homeland Security Committee unanimously passed Congressman Lee Zeldin’s bill yesterday to prevent the sale of Plum Island to the highest bidder, releasing the bill from committee for a vote on the house floor this year.

Original Story Follows:

The effort to preserve Plum Island could get a shot in the arm this Thursday, April 28, when Congressman Lee Zeldin says he expects a bill he introduced to halt the sale of the island to be marked up and voted out of committee for a vote on the floor of the U.S. House of Representatives.

The 2008 legislation authorizing the closure of the lab and the construction of a new lab in Manhattan, Kansas, had required the Department of Homeland Security, which manages the island, to prepare it for a public auction.

Attempts to decouple the construction of the new lab from the required sale of the island have languished in Congress since first proposed in 2013,  but Mr. Zeldin said a drastically reworded “amendment in the form of a substitute” to the bill outlining steps to be taken to explore other potential federal uses of the island, expected to be marked up by the House Homeland Security Committee Thursday, “is expected to pass the committee nearly unanimously.”

Mr. Zeldin, who held a press conference at Riverhead’s Reeves Park Beach Sunday morning to announce the anticipated vote, said he expects Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut to introduce a mirror bill in the senate once the house bill is released from committee. Mr. Zeldin said he hopes the bill makes it to President Barack Obama’s desk for signature before the president leaves office at the end of this year.

The legislation to be voted on by the committee April 28 is an “amendment in the form of a substitute,” replacing the entire text of Mr. Zeldin’s original bill, to be introduced by Homeland Security Committee member Dan Donovan, a congressman from Staten Island.

“The hangup in the current form was that the federal government didn’t have a vision of what to do next,” said Mr. Zeldin. “We would have been happy if the sale was stopped, but then what?”

An email advertising a tour of Plum Island for prospective buyers.
An email advertising a tour of Plum Island for prospective buyers.

Mr. Zeldin said the new bill directs the General Accounting Office to perform a detailed study of the future options for Plum Island if the coalition of agencies and citizen groups working to preserve the island aren’t happy with a Department of Homeland Security study currently underway.

Attempts to sell the island would be halted during the studies, and for 180 days after the GAO study is sent to Congress.

The Department of Homeland Security report is required, according to the new amendment, to examine “the possible alternative uses for Plum Island, including the transfer of ownership to another Federal agency, a State or local government, a nonprofit organization, or a combination thereof for the purpose of education, research, or conservation.”

The report is also required to detail the implications of these alternative uses, and the “potential cost to be incurred for expenses related to the transition, cleanup, and hazard mitigation of Plum Island by a recipient of such property.”

Preserve Plum Island Coalition spokesman John Turner came to the press conference with a printout of an email sent out by a real estate agent with The Corcoran Group inviting potential purchasers to tour the island and participate in a “90 minute discussion, where your thoughts on Plum Island’s unique attributes and reuse potential will be instrumental in assisting the Government in positioning of the property for sale.”

Mr. Turner said he looks forward to Plum Island being off the auction block by next Earth Day.

Chris Cryder of Save the Sound said his group’s message, and that of the more than 60 other agencies in the Preserve Plum Island Coalition, is simple.

“We want to see the rest of the island preserved, not bulldozed and sold as a golf course,” he said, adding that the groups would also like to see the research laboratory kept in use.

“We have a chance to make real progress,” he said. “The General Accounting Office Conservation Alternatives Report is a crucial first step.”

State Assemblyman Anthony Palumbo praised Mr. Zeldin as a “man of action,” and added that the fact that “a particular presidential candidate may put a golf course with a landing strip for his own personal jet” on Plum Island “is offensive to us all.”

Scott Russell credits Al Krupski for the decision to zone Plum Island.
Scott Russell credits Al Krupski for the decision to zone Plum Island.

Southold Town’s decision three years ago to zone Plum Island — which had been in federal hands since before zoning was enacted in Southold — helped lay the groundwork to squash development efforts. The island can now only be used for a research institution and a wildlife preserve.

Southold Town Supervisor Scott Russell credited the idea to County Legislator Al Krupski, who was a Southold Town Councilman at the time.

“Al Krupski said ‘we’ve gotta do something,” and I said ‘who would be crazy enough to buy Plum Island,” said Scott Russell. “Then we got the call from Donald Trump’s representative, who wanted to put a golf course there.

Mr. Zeldin said he knows of only one developer, Mr. Trump, who expressed interest in purchasing the island.

“He had a different vision for making Plum Island great again,” he said. “We believe it is already great.”

“For many years, many of you have worked hard on this effort,” said Mr. Zeldin. “I hope President Obama will sign this legislation before leaving office. We have the momentum and we hope to seize it.”

Beth Young
Beth Young is an award-winning local journalist who has been covering the East End since the 1990s. She began her career at the Sag Harbor Express and, after receiving her Masters from the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, has reported for the Southampton Press, the East Hampton Press and the Times/Review Media Group. She founded the East End Beacon website in 2013, and a print edition in 2017. Beth was born and raised on the North Fork. In her spare time, she tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human: