One of E.A. Brooks' carvings on the Long Island Sound shore
One of E.A. Brooks’ carvings on the Long Island Sound shore

There’s little record left of the Poquatuck Indians of Orient, except for a fisherman’s tribute carved into the rocks on the Long Island Sound shore in the 1930s, and even that record appears to be fading as time and storms weather the rocks.

It isn’t easy to find Orient fisherman Elliot Alvah Brooks’ stone carvings, which he dedicated to the “memory of the vanquished Poquatucks,” along the shore of the Long Island Sound, and people who live in Orient like to keep it that way.

When I begged to see them on a recent Tuesday afternoon, I was blindfolded and led to the passenger seat of the truck owned by one of the few people who knows how to find them. We drove for what seemed like ages down a bumpy dirt road, then parked as I was led by the hand down to the cliff’s edge.

At first, all there is to see is a jumbled pile of  rocks deposited by the receding glacier that created Long Island, but as you sit and study, you realize you are in the middle of  history.

E.A. Brooks, the name he used to sign his carvings and paintings, called his boulder project “Bear Rock Studio.” In total, he carved 25 figures in the rocks over the course of several years beginning in 1933. Most of them are of the faces of Poquatuck Indians, but in a complete stylistic departure, one is of the outline of a polar bear, four feet high, facing out toward the Sound. The carvings have since been cataloged by the Smithsonian Institution.

“I tried chiseling out some figures, and being a great lover of Indian lore, conceived the idea of leaving a monument to the vanquished Poquatucks,” he said in an interview in the historical society’s records.

[easingsliderpro id=”13″]

Mr. Brooks was born in 1888 and died in 1949. He lived at the corner of Navy and Orchard streets and was buried just down the road from his home at Orient Central Cemetery, said Amy Folk, the collections manager at the Oysterponds Historical Society in Orient.

He was known throughout Orient for his knowledge of Poquatuck lore and his collection of Native American artifacts.

Along with his brother Frank, he began painting late in life under the tutelage of Hortense Knox, and began carving boulders along the sound shore in 1933, said Geoffrey Fleming, director of the Southold Historical Society, who said Mr. Brooks’ paintings weren’t of serious note.

“He was not a great painter, but he was one of the painters out here,” he said. “He was part of the Orient group.”

Ms. Folk said, at one point, the Oysterponds Historical Society had considered moving the rocks to the historical society’s headquarters, but the logistics of moving the heavy boulders and the legal issues regarding who owns which sections of the intertidal shoreline have kept them in place where Mr. Brooks carved them.

“That didn’t really fly,” she said of the move.

The photographs on file at the historical society, taken at regular intervals since the carvings were made, show the gradual deterioration of the stones. But even some 2006 photographs in the collection seem much more clear than the stones do today.

“You aren’t going to tell anyone where they are?” asked Ms. Folk when she heard about this article. “People have to be very careful not to damage them.”

No, I’m not telling. I don’t know where they are. But I’m glad I had the chance to see them before the memory of the carvings becomes as blurry in our collective consciousness as the memory of the vanquished Poquatucks is now.


Beth Young
Beth Young is an award-winning local journalist who has been covering the East End since the 1990s. She began her career at the Sag Harbor Express and, after receiving her Masters from the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, has reported for the Southampton Press, the East Hampton Press and the Times/Review Media Group. She founded the East End Beacon website in 2013, and a print edition in 2017. Beth was born and raised on the North Fork. In her spare time, she tinkers with bicycles, tries not to drown in the Peconic Bay and hopes to grow the perfect tomato. You can send her a message at

8 thoughts on “Orient’s treasure on the edge of the sea

  1. Terrific article. I have an old folder in my archives about these carvings. It’s from the 1960’s and was in the NY Times.If I can find it I will pass it along to you.
    I received it from an old birding buddy of mine a few years ago, she has seen the carvings as well..
    Her name is Zu Proly and is now 95 years old. She had just retired from teaching in Sea Cliff when I started birding. She joined us for a 4 day birding trip the third week last May in Frost Valley NY. She still works at a soup kitchen in Glen Cove. She was part of our group when we birded the NW USA and Canada about 10 years ago. She told me she and her girlfriends biked over the Rockies just before WWII. In 1990’s she went through Canada to bird Cuba. Way ahead of her time as a liberated person. AMAZING Woman.

  2. I have known and loved these carvings since I was a child. My family owned beach front property very near to the site. It is wonderful to see them recognized for the treasure they are! And yes, I know exactly where they are but my lips are sealed!

  3. I grew up with these carvings because Elliot is my great, great uncle. Thank you for keeping the location a secret, and thank you even more for writing this article.

  4. I last saw these carvings around 1950 when shown by my father A. Halsey Brown. Also of note is a carving by my father on Auters Island in East Marion. He carved his initials A H B

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you're human: